|
|
A:N:S Chorus Discography |
Pál Benkő, András Demjén, Zoltán Gavodi, Csaba Gyulai, Nigel Heavey, Ádám Kard, Zoltán Kalmanovits, András Koncz, Miklós Laczkovich, Zoltán Mizsei, Péter Patay, Tamás Pintér, Ferenc Tőkés Bodor, András Soós
Recorded between 17-24 September 2004, Roman Catholic Church at Makkosmária
Recording producer: András Wilheim
Sound engineer: Domokos Tímár
Edited by Zsuzsa Dvorák
Released in August 2005
::
Péter Bárány,
Zoltán Gavodi,
Nigel Heavey, Péter Patay, Csaba Gyulai, Ádám Kard,
Miklós Laczkovich, Ferenc Tőkés Bodor, Zoltán Kalmanovits, András Koncz, Zoltán Mizsei , Tamás Pintér, András Soós, Pál Benkő, András Demjén, László Heim, György Jólesz
Recorded between: 5-11 September 2003,
Roman Catholic Church at Makkosmária
Recording producer: András Wilheim
Sound engineer: István Zakariás
Edited by Zsuzsa Dvorák
Released in June 2004
Sponsored by the Cultural Committee of the General Assembly of Budapest
Péter Bárány, Zoltán Gavodi,
Nigel Heavey, Péter Patay, Csaba Gyulai, Ádám Kard,
Miklós Laczkovich, Ferenc Tőkés Bodor, Zoltán Kalmanovits, András Koncz, Zoltán Mizsei, András Soós, Pál Benkő, András Demjén,
Tamás Pintér
Recorded between 14-22 October 2002, Roman Catholic Church at Makkosmária
Recording producer: András Wilheim
Sound engineer: István Zakariás
Edited by Zsuzsa Dvorák
Released in June 2003
Sponsored by the Cultural Committee of the General Assembly of Budapest
|
www.medieval.org Among the three best recordings of the year selected by Todd McComb |
|
"Wrapping up the year's best releases of c.1500 polyphony, the A:N:S Chorus returns with a third issue in their Obrecht series. Although this program is not as striking as in their previous Obrecht releases, the addition of two more previously unrecorded masses is critical to a developing understanding of how Obrecht's works present themselves in sound. Only a short time ago, he was even more neglected than La Rue, but now we can begin to perceive some 'standards' of Obrecht's idiom. In this case, the Missa De Sancto Donatiano is an uneven work, based more closely on the style of Ockeghem, whereas the Missa Sicut spina rosam takes a similarly motivated style to a more masterful level. The latter is sure to become a favorite in Obrecht's oeuvre. The A:N:S Chorus continues to be one of the most prepared and energetic ensembles performing this repertory, and the present release does nothing to change that impression." |
|
Diapason, November 2003
David Fiala |
|
[The CD was given the highest (5*) grade by Diapason]
„L’intégrale des messes d’Obrecht entamné par l’excellent choeur d’hommes hongrois A:N:S est un événement, et a saluer bien bas […]" |
|
International Record Review,
February 2004
Alison Bullock |
|
„[…] János Bali’s group appeared out of the blue in 1999 with a highly acclaimed recording of two Obrecht Masses ( O lumen ecclesie and Malheur me bat), following it up a year later with the masses Si dedero and Pfauenschwanz, and now it has done it again. This is a shrewd pairing, because both these Masses, although probably written some 13 years apart, show Obrecht at his least Obrechtian, quoting from and emulating the style of the older Ockeghem. The lack of Obrecht’s characteristic thytmic drive and direct expression makes them a challenge to pull off, but ANS Chorus does it with flair and bravado. […] All in all, this is a very impressive disc, and, for specialists, a fascinating foil to the English polish of the Clercs’ Group’s disc." |
|
::
Péter Bárány, Zoltán Gavodi, Nigel
Heavey, Péter Patay - countertenor Csaba Gyulai, Ádám Kard,
Miklós Laczkovich - tenor Zoltán Kalmanovits, András Koncz,
Zoltán Mizsei, András Sós - baritone
Pál Benkô, András Demjén,
Tamás Pintér- bass
Recorded between 19-21 June
and 2-4 July 2000. Recording Producer: András
Wilheim, Sound engineers: István Zakariás,
Csintalan László, Edited by Dvorák Zsuzsa
Released in May 2001
Sponsored
by the Cultural Committee of the General Assembly of
Budapest
|
Péter Bárány, Nigel Heavey, Péter Patay -
countertenor Csaba Gyulai, Ádám Kard, Miklós Laczkovich, Rezsõ
Kutik - tenor Zoltán Kalmanovits, András Koncz, Zoltán Mizsei,
András Soós - baritone Pál Benkõ, András Demjén, Tamás Pintér -
bass
Recorded in June 1999 Recording
Producer: András Wilheim, Sound Engineer:
István Zakariás, Edited by: Péterdi Péter
Released in December 2000 Sponsored
by: the Soros Foundation, Budapest Available
through Amazon.com,
CDworld,
CDnow
Also available through: HUNGAROTON
|
www.medieval.org Todd
McComb: Medieval & Renaissance Recordings of the Year -
2000 |
|
"[...] The second Obrecht
recording by János Bali's ensemble is certainly no
disappointment, forming a worthy successor to the first.
Although that first recording made the greater impact, coming
out of (seemingly) nowhere as it did with such an amazing
confidence and compelling presentation of some of Obrecht's
best music, if anything, the next recording is even more
abstract and intriguing. [...]" | |
Péter Bárány, Zoltán Gavodi, Nigel
Heavey, Péter Patay - countertenor Csaba Gyulai, Ádám Kard,
Miklós Laczkovich - tenor Zoltán Kalmanovits, András Koncz,
Zoltán Mizsei, András Soós – baritone Pál Benkõ, András Demjén,
Tamás Pintér – bass
Recorded on: February 1998,
Recording Producer: András Wilheim,
Sound engineer: István Zakariás,
Edited
by Katalin Pusztási
Released in January
1999 Sponsored by: the Cultural Committee of the
General Assembly of Budapest Available through: CDworld,
Amazon.com,
CDnow
Also available through: HUNGAROTON
|
www.medieval.org Todd
McComb |
|
"[...] The performance is
excellent, showing a great command of the music. Although I am
not generally in favor of ensembles of this size, they manage
to achieve articulation which is more clear than smaller
ensembles have done here. The phrasing is forceful &
expressive, while maintaining the flow of Obrecht's music over
longer structures. It is very impressive, and not the least
bit shallow or tentative. [...]" |
|
Gramophone
(London) October 1999, p. 108., F[abrice] F[itch]: Obrecht
Sacred Choral Works |
|
"[...] The presumably early Mass
O lumen ecclesiae is new to the catalogue, but the choir’s
rendition of the later setting on Malheur me bat compares
favourably with existing recordings – technically very
assured, it contributes a sound-image that captures (better
than does The Clerks’ Group on ASV, 5/98) the brooding
waywardness of Obrecht’s invention. Worth seeking out." |
|
Muzsika vol 42. #10.
October 1999, pp. 41-42. in: János Malina: Obrecht, Michael
Haydn - and what lies between. Thoughts on early music from
Hungaroton Classics. (in Hungarian)) . |
|
"[...] Bali and his choir have
produced an enchantingly beautiful disc. [...] " |
|
Early Music Rewiew 56.
December 1999, p. 20. D. James Ross: Obrecht: Missa O lumen
ecclesiae (etc.) |
|
"[...] The 14 singers, with four
male altos on the top line, give a thoroughly creditable
account of both masses and motets, and János Bali demonstrates
a deep understanding of the idiom and indeed the musicological
context of the works.[...] These are extremely presentable
performances of rarely recorded repertoire and are well worth
buying." |
|
www.medieval.org Todd
McComb: Medieval & Renaissance Recordings of the Year -
1999 |
|
[One of the four candidates for
the Record of the Year 1999] "[...] This is direct
music-making based on sincerity, not pseudo-dramatic funny
stuff, and this group consequently deserves more attention.
[...]" |
|
Gramophon (London),
January 2000, p. 39. , CRITICS' CHOICE / Fabrice Fitch
|
|
"[...] these performances remind
us of just how dynamic and visible the Hungarian early music
scene has become." |
|
Early Music, February
2000, pp. 125-126., in: Jenny Hodgson: I Fiamminghi
|
|
"[...] Despite adhering to a
composer-based interpretation of the mensural relationships,
the ANS nonetheless manages to prevent any lessening of the
Obrechtian drama: musical lines are vigorously shaped to give
the feeling of a frenetic pace (although technically they are
not particularly speedy), while the transposition down a 3rd
[...] thickens the texture in slower passages and gives the
Mass [M. Malheur me bat] truly caliginous overtones.
[...]" | | |